1

The Cohen Report: What is the National Average Charge for 10,500 HCPCS Codes?

Frank writes:

I have finally completed my analysis of the 2009/2010 P/SPS (Physician/Supplier Procedure Summary) Master File.  This file contains 100% of all claims submitted to Medicare during a given calendar year, along with a mid-year 5% update. For this analysis, I used around 2.5 billion claim lines that represent nearly every physician in every specialty in the US. For this run, I analyzed the charges submitted to the database and created a file that reports the national average charge for over 10,500 procedure codes.  Each procedure code (and modifier, when applicable), report the weighted average charge, the variation (standard deviation) and the sample error. The latter two will allow you to determine the value of the point estimate.

From the Report:

Level 1        Office/outpatient visit, est     38.11

Level 2        Office/outpatient visit, est     65.04

Level 3        Office/outpatient visit, est     92.54

Level 4        Office/outpatient visit, est     140.74

Level 5        Office/outpatient visit, est     198.77

Remember, even though the data come from the Medicare database, our studies show that nearly 95% of all providers submit their retail (or usual) charge so that this is an excellent source for a fee schedule analysis.

To get this file (at no charge),

go to www.frankcohengroup.com and click on the Download tab. When you get to the download page, it will be the second link down.

Also, I am going to be the keynote speaker

(as well as conducting some break-out sessions) for the 2011 Physicians RAC Summit to be held in Orlando, FL the second week of January. I am going to be talking about two major issues; how to assess your risk for an audit and then how to determine whether the post-audit overpayment estimates are calculated properly. So far, in nearly every analysis I have conducted, the overpayment estimate was wrong and, not surprisingly, biased towards the RAC, not the provider. To get more information, go to my website at www.frankcohengroup.com and click on the RAC Summit link.

Please let me know if you have any questions or if I can be of assistance in any way.

Frank Cohen, MPA, MBB

www.frankcohengroup.com

frank@frankcohengroup.com




What Health Care Providers Need To Know About Medicare and the RAC

Carla Hannibal

By Carla Hannibal, CMM,CPM,CIMBS

Recovery Audit Contractors (RACs) will pursue corrections of Medicare claims by auditing for overpayments and underpayments under Part A or B of the title XVIII of the Social Security Act.  Health care providers will be affected as Medicare has recently contracted with RACs for 2009 and beyond.  RACs will audit every United States and Peurto Rico health care provider who files with Medicare.  The audit and recovery plan is expected to be in place by 2010 in all 50 states and Puerto Rico on a permanent basis. Based on findings, if compliance with Medicare billing rules is not up to standard, penalties may be assessed including fines and in severe cases, the loss of Medicare billing privileges.

What should providers do?
Health care providers would be wise to ensure their offices are in compliance because Medicare will not provide any specific guidance to the physician or provider of care outside of basic written guidelines.  RAC contracts fees are contingency-based which means they will have every incentive to find errors.  It should be noted that each RAC’s contingency fee is established during contract negotiations with CMS and varies for each RAC.

Region A: 12.45%
Region B: 12.50%
Region C: 9.00%
Region D: 9.49%

For practices, internal changes need to be established to monitor documentation and coding for compliance as well as establishing a framework to track RAC requests.  These are not new requirements to providers.  The provider application and contract clearly states that it is the sole responsibility of the Physician to follow all documentation rules and regulations, coding and billing rules 100% of the time.  Offices setting up compliance guidelines should appoint someone who will be responsible for monitoring compliance within the practice.

Is there a limit to what records RACs will audit?

Yes there is a medical records limit, established by NPI, of records the RAC will audit.

Ӣ Solo Practitioner
Limit = 10 medical records/45 days

Ӣ Partnership of 2-5 individuals
Limit = 20 medical records/45 days

Ӣ Group of 6-15 individuals
Limit = 30 medical records/45 days

Ӣ Large Group (16+ individuals)
Limit = 50 medical records/45 days

What are the RACs focusing on?

Under the program, RACs will focus on CMS-established payment criteria and will consist of both automated claims history reviews from the CMS database as well as complex clinical reviews of patient medical records.   Specific areas of concentration include “not medically necessary services” (or those not meeting the established CMS clinical payment criteria), non-covered services, incorrectly coded claims, duplicate services and incorrect payment amounts.

What is involved in the RAC claims audit process?

The Process consists of six phases.

I.     Data Screening & Claim Selection

II.    Medical Record Request

III.  Record Review and Status Determination

IV.  Post Review Notification

V.    Overpayment Recoupment

VI.   Post Determination- Other Provider Options and Data Tracking

Does the RAC program cover Medicare Replacement policies?

No the RAC program does not detect or correct payments for Medicare Advantage or the Medicare prescription drug benefit.

What happens after a RAC audit?

In those cases of overpayments, the physicians may choose to send a rebuttal of the findings directly to the RAC within 15 days of receiving the RAC’s letter identifying an overpayment.  However this does not stop the clock on the 120-day time period during which you can request a redetermination (first level appeal) from your Medicare contractor or on the interest accrued when money is not refunded to CMS within 30 days of request.  If the RAC discovers that an underpayment has been made to the provider then the RAC will inform the carrier or intermediary who will proceed with the claim adjustment and payment to the provider.

When does all this begin?

Implementation will take place on a rolling basis in 3 phases which began 10/1/08.  The schedule for the program rollout can be found here.


Will your practice be ready?


Carla Hannibal, CMM, CPM, CIMBS is President of Hannibal Professional Services, LLC (HPS).  HPS is a practice management company that provides services for small to medium-sized physician groups.  Carla is a writer, speaker, trainer and highly skilled manager with 27 years of clinical and administrative experience in the healthcare industry.  Her experience in the healthcare industry ranges from claims processing to practice management.  If you need more information on RAC, or help in implementing a compliance process in your practice, Carla can be reached at 623- 204-8992.